IRELAND UNDER COERCION
THE DIARY OF AN AMERICAN
BY
WILLIAM HENRY HURLBERT
VOL. II.
SECOND EDITION.
1888
“Upon the future of Ireland hangs the future of the British Empire.”
CARDINAL MANNING TO EARL GREY, 1868
CONTENTS OF VOL. II.
CHAPTER VII.
- Rossbehy, Feb. 21, 1
- The latest eviction at Glenbehy, 1
- Trafalgar Square, 1, 2
- Father Little, 3
- Mr. Frost, 3, 4
- Priest and landlord, 3
- Savings Banks’ deposits at Six-mile Bridge, 5
- Drive through Limerick, 5
- Population and trade, 5, 6
- Boycotting and commerce, 6, 7
- Shores of the Atlantic, 7
- Tralee, 7
- Killorglin, 8
- Hostelry in the hills, 8
- Facts of the eviction, 9-13
- Glenbehy Eviction Fund (see Note G2), 12
- A walk on Washington’s birthday, 13
- A tenant at Glenbehy offers £13 in two instalments in full for £240 arrears, 13
- English and Irish members, 14
- “Winn’s Folly,” 15
- Acreage and rental of the Glenbehy estate, 16
- Work of eviction begun, 17
- Patience of officers, 17
- American and Irish evictions contrasted, 17
- “Oh, he’s quite familiar,” 18
- A modest Poor Law Guardian, 18, 19
- Moonlighters’ swords, 20
- Father Quilter and the “poor slaves,” his people, 21,22
- Beauty of Lough Caragh, 23
- Difficulty of getting evidence, 25
- Effects of terrorism in Kerry, 25
- Singular identification of a murderer, 26
- Local administration in Tralee, 28
CHAPTER VIII.
- Cork, Feb. 23, 30
- Press accounts of Glenbehy evictions
CHAPTER IX.
- Feb. 28, 82
- Portumna, Galway, 82
- Run through Cork, Limerick, Tipperary, Queen’s and King’s County to Parsonstown, 82
- A Canadian priest on the situation, 83
- His reply to M. de Mandat Grancey, 83
- Relations of priests with the League, 83-85
- Parsonstown and Lord Rosse, 86
- Drive to Portumna, 87
- An abandoned railway, 88
- American storms, grain, and beasts, 88, 89
- Portumna Castle, 90, 91
- Lord Clanricarde’s estate, 92
- Mr. Tener, 92-128
- Plan of Campaign, 94-99
- Ability of tenants to pay their rents, 95
- Mr. Dillon in 1886, 96
- Mr. Parnell in 1885, 97
- Tenants in greater danger than landlords and agents, 100
- Feb. 29, 100
- Conference between evicted tenants and agent, 100-106
- Castle and park, 107
- The League shopkeeper and tenant, 108
- Under police escort, 109
- Cost of ‘knocking’ a man, 109
- What constitutes a group,
CHAPTER X.
- Dublin, March 1, 135
- Portumna to Woodford, 135
- Evictions of October 1887, 135
- Capture of Cloondadauv Castle, 137-141
- A tenant and a priest, 141-144
- Workmen’s wages in Massachusetts compared with the profits of a tenant farmer in Ireland, 146
- Loughrea, 148, 149
- Murder of Finlay, 150, 151
- The chrysoprase Lake of Loughrea, 154
- Lord Clanricarde’s estate office, acreage, and rental, 155
- Woodford acreage and rental, 155,156
- Drive from Loughrea to Woodlawn, 156-160
- A Galway “jarvey” on the situation, 156-159
- Woodlawn and the Ashtown
CHAPTER XI.
- Borris, March 2, 161
- Mr. Kavanagh, 161-163
- Borris House, 163-167
- A living Banshee, 165, 166
- Land Corporation—its mode of working, 167
- Meeting in Dublin, 1885, 168
- Rev. Mr. Cantwell, 168
- Lord Lansdowne’s property at Luggacurren, 169
- Mr. Kavanagh’s career, 170
- Books and papers at Borris, 171
- Strongbow, 172
- “The five bloods,” 172, 173
- Genealogy of M‘Morroghs and Kavanaghs, 173
- March 4, 174
- Protestant service read every morning, 174
- A Catholic gentleman’s views, 175
- Relation of tenants to village despots, 176
- Would America make a State of Ireland? 177
- Land Acts since 1870, 178
- The O’Grady of Kilballyowen and his rental, 179
- Dispute with his tenants: its cause and effect, 180
- His circular to his tenantry, 181-186
CHAPTER XII.
- Grenane House, March 5, 187
- Visit to Mr. Seigne, 187
- Beautiful situation of Grenane, 189
- A lady of the country, 189
- Mr. Seigne’s experience of the tenants, 191-194
- The beauty of Woodstock, 194-198
- The watch of Waterloo, 197-200
- Curious discovery of stolen property, 200
- Dublin, March 6, 200
- State of deposits in the Savings Banks, 200-201
- Interest on “Plan of Campaign” funds, 202
CHAPTER XIII.
- Dublin, March 8, 203
CHAPTER XIV.
- Dublin, March 9, 219
- Athy, 219
- A political jarvey, 220-225
- “Who is Mr. Gilhooly?” 221
- Lord Lansdowne’s offer refused through pressure of the League, 226
- Mr. Kilbride, M.P., and Mr. Dunne, 226-228
- Lord Lansdowne’s estate in Kerry, 228-231
- Plan of Campaign at Luggacurren, 231-236
- Interview with Father Maher, 236-239
- A “jarvey” on a J.P., 240
- “Railway amenities,” 241
- Dublin, March 10, 242
- Mr. Brooke, 242-248
- Unreasonable tenants, 243, 244
- Size and rental of estate, 246
- Sub-commissioner’s reduction reversed, 246, 247
CHAPTER XV.
- Maryborough, 249
- Archbishop Croke, 249
- Interviews with labourers, 251-253
- Views of a successful country teacher, 254, 255
- A veteran of the ’48, 256-
CHAPTER XVI.
- Belfast, June 25, 313
- Ulster in Irish history, 313
- Moira, 315
- Views of an Ulsterman, 315, 316
- Beauty of Belfast, 317, 318
- Its buildings, 319-321
- Dr. Hanna, 322-324
- Dr. Kane, 325
- June 26, 326
- Sir John Preston,
EPILOGUE, p. 333-349
APPENDIX.
NOTES—
- F. The Moonlighters and Home Rule (pp. 10, 38), 351
- G. The Ponsonby Property (pp. 59-66), 353
- G2. The Glenbehy Eviction Fund (p. 12), 360
- G3. Home Rule and Protestantism (p. 68), 362
- H. Tully and the Woodford Evictions (p. 149), 364
- H2. Boycotting the Dead (p. 151), 370
- I. The Savings Banks (P.O.) (vol. i. p. 39, vol. ii. pp. 5 and 200), 371
- K. The Coolgreany Evictions (p. 216), 372
- L. A Ducal Supper in 1711 (p. 283), 374
- M. Letter from Mr. O’Leary (p. 291), 375
- N. Boycotting Private Opinion (p. 293), 377
- O. Boycotting by Crowner’s Quest Law (p. 312), 382
ROSSBEHY,1 Feb. 21.—We are here on the eve of battle! An “eviction” is to be made to-morrow on the Glenbehy 1 estate of Mr. Winn, an uncle of Lord Headley, so upon the invitation of Colonel Turner, who has come to see that all is done decently and in order, I left Ennis with him at 7.40 A.M. for Limerick; the “city of the Liberator” for “the city of the Broken Treaty.” There we breakfasted at the Artillery Barracks.
The officers showed us there the new twelve-pounder gun with its elaborately scientific machinery, its Scotch sight, and its four-mile range. I compared notes about the Trafalgar Square riots of February 1886 with an Irish officer who happened to have been on the opposite side of Pall Mall from me at the moment when the mob, getting out of the hand of my socialistic friend Mr. Hyndman, and advancing towards St. James’ Street and Piccadilly was broken by a skilful and very spirited charge of the police. He gave a most humorous account of his own sensations when he first came into contact with the multitude after emerging from St. Paul’s, where, as he put it, he had left the people “all singing away like devils.” But I found he quite agreed with me in thinking that there was a visible nucleus of something like military organisation in the mob of that day, which was overborne and, as it were, smothered by the mere mob element before it came to trying conclusions with the police.
On our way to Limerick, Colonel Turner caught sight, at a station, of Father Little, the parish priest of Six Mile Bridge, in County Clare, and jumping out of the carriage invited him to get in and pursue his journey with us, which he very politely did. Father Little is a tall fine-looking man of a Saxon rather than a Celtic type, and I daresay comes of the Cromwellian stock. He is a staunch and outspoken Nationalist, and has been made rather prominent of late by his championship of certain of his parishioners in their contest with their landlord, Mr. H.V. D’Esterre, who lives chiefly at Bournemouth in England, but owns 2833 acres in County Clare at Rosmanagher, valued at £1625 a year. More than a year ago one of Father Little’s parishioners, Mr. Frost, successfully resisted a large force of the constabulary bent on executing a process of ejectment against him obtained by Mr. D’Esterre.
Frost’s holding was of 33 Irish, or, in round numbers, about 50 English, acres, at a rental of £117, 10s., on which he had asked but had not obtained an abatement. The Poor-Law valuation of the holding was £78, and Frost estimated the value of his and his father’s improvements, including the homestead and the offices, or in other words his tenant-right, at £400. The authorities sent a stronger body of constables and ejected Frost. But as soon as they had left the place Frost came back with his family, on the 28th Jan. 1887, and reoccupied it. Of course proceedings were taken against him immediately, and a small war was waged over the Frost farm until the 5th of September last, when an expedition was sent against it, and it was finally captured, and Frost evicted with his family. Upon this last occasion Father Little (who gave me a very temperate but vigorous account of the whole affair) distinguished himself by a most ingenious and original attempt to “hold the fort.” He chained himself to the main doorway, and stretching the chains right and left secured them to two other doors. It was of this refreshing touch of humour that I heard the other day at Abbeyleix as happening not in Clare but in Kerry.
Since his eviction Frost has been living, Father Little tells me, in a wooden hut put up for him on the lands of a kinsman of the same name, who is also a tenant of Mr. D’Esterre, and who has since been served by his landlord with a notice of ejectment for arrears, although he had paid up six months’ dues two months only before the service. Father Little charged the landlord in this case with prevarication and other evasive proceedings in the course of his negotiations with the tenants; and Colonel Turner did not contest the statements made by him in support of his contention that the Rosmanagher difficulty might have been avoided had the tenants been more fairly and more considerately dealt with. It is strong presumptive evidence against the landlord that a kinsman, Mr. Robert D’Esterre, is one of the subscribers to a fund raised by Father Little in aid of the evicted man Frost. On the other hand, as illustrating the condition of the tenants, it is noteworthy that the Post-Office Savings Bank’s deposits at Six-Mile Bridge rose from £382, 17s. 10d. in 1880 to £934, 13s. 4d. in 1887. After breakfast we took a car and drove rapidly about the city for an hour. With its noble river flowing through the very heart of the place, and broadening soon into an estuary of the Atlantic, Limerick ought long ago to have taken its place in the front rank of British ports dealing with the New World. In the seventeenth century it was the fourth city of Ireland, Boate putting it then next after Dublin, Galway, and Waterford. Belfast at that time, he describes as a place hardly comparable “to a small market-town in England.” To-day Limerick has a population of some forty thousand, and Belfast a population of more than two hundred thousand souls. This change cannot be attributed solely, if at all, to the “Protestant ascendency,” nor yet to the alleged superiority of the Northern over the Southern Irish in energy and thrift, For in the seventeenth century Limerick was more important than Cork, whereas it had so far fallen behind its Southern competitor in the eighteenth century that it contained in 1781 but 3859 houses, while Cork contained 5295. To-day its population is about half as large as that of Cork. It is a very well built city, its main thoroughfare, George Street, being at least a mile in length, and a picturesque city also, thanks to the island site of its most ancient quarter, the English Town, and to the hills of Clare and Killaloe, which close the prospect of the surrounding country. But the streets, though many of them are handsome, have a neglected look, as have also the quays and bridges. One of my companions, to whom I spoke of this, replied, “if they look neglected, it’s because they are neglected. Politics are the death of the place, and the life of its publics.”2
As we approached the shores of the Atlantic from Limerick, the scenery became very grand and beautiful. On the right of the railway the country rolled and undulated away towards the Stacks, amid the spurs and slopes of which, in the wood of Clonlish, Sanders, the Nuncio sent over to organise Catholic Ireland against Elizabeth, miserably perished of want and disease six years before the advent of the great Armada. To the south-west rose the grand outlines of the Macgillicuddy’s Reeks, the highest points, I believe, in the South of Ireland. We established ourselves at the County Kerry Club on our arrival in Tralee, which I
We left the Sheriff and the escort to find their way as best they could after us.
Mrs. Shee, the landlady here, ushered us into a very pretty room hung with little landscapes of the country, and made cheery by a roaring fire. Two or three officers of the soldiers sent on here to prevent any serious uproar to-morrow dined with us.
The constabulary are in force, but in great good humour. They have no belief that there will be any trouble, though all sorts of wild tales were flying about Tralee before we left, of English members of Parliament coming down to denounce the “Coercion” law, and of risings in the hills, and I know not what besides. The agent of the Winn property, or of Mr. Head of Reigate in Surrey, the mortgagee of the estate, who holds a power of attorney from Mr. Winn, is here, a quiet, intelligent young man, who has given me the case in a nut-shell.
The tenant to be evicted, James Griffin, is the son and heir of one Mrs. Griffin, who on the 5th of April 1854 took a lease of the lands known as West Lettur from the then Lord Headley and the Hon. R. Winn, at the annual rent of £32, 10s. This rent has since been reduced by a judicial process to £26. In 1883 James Griffin, who was then, as he is now, an active member of the local branch of the National League, and who was imprisoned under Mr. Gladstone’s Act of 1881 as a “suspect,” was evicted, being then several years in arrears. He re-entered unlawfully immediately afterwards, and has remained in West Lettur unlawfully ever since, actively deterring and discouraging other tenants from paying their rents. He took a great part in promoting the refusal to pay which led to the famous evictions of last year. As to these, it seems the tenants had agreed, in 1886, to accept a proposition from Mr. Head, remitting four-fifths of all their arrears upon payment of one year’s rent and costs. Mr. Sheehan, M.P., a hotel-keeper in Killarney, intervened, advising the tenants that the Dublin Parliament would soon be established, and would abolish “landlordism,” whereupon they refused to keep their agreement.3 Sir Redvers Buller, who then filled the post now held by Sir West Ridgway, seeing this alarming deadlock, urged Mr. Head to go further, and offer to take a half-year’s rent and costs. If the tenants refused this Sir Redvers advised Mr. Head to destroy all houses occupied by mere trespassers, such as Griffin, who, if they could hold a place for twelve years, would acquire a title under the Statute of Limitations. A negotiation conducted by Sir Redvers and Father Quilter, P.P., followed, and Father Quilter, for the tenants, finally, in writing, accepted Mr. Head’s offer, under which, by the payment of £865, they would be rid of a legal liability for £6177. The League again intervened with bribes and threats, and Father Quilter found himself obliged to write to Colonel Turner a letter in which he said, “Only seventeen of the seventy tenants have sent on their rents to Mr. Roe (the agent). Though promising that they would accept the terms, they have withdrawn at the last moment from fulfilment.... I shall never again during my time in Glenbehy interfere between a landlord and his tenants. I have poor slaves who will not keep their word. Now let Mr. Roe or any other agent in future deal with Glenbeighans as he likes.” The farms lie at a distance even from this inn, and very far therefore from Killorglin, and the agent, knowing that the tenants would be encouraged by Griffin and by Mr. Harrington, M.P., and others, to come back into their holdings as soon as the officers withdrew, ordered the woodwork of several cottages to be burned in order to prevent this. This burning of the cottages, which were the lawful property of the mortgagee, made a great figure in the newspaper reports, and “scandalised the civilised world.” The present agent thinks it was impolitic on that account, but he has no doubt it was a good thing financially for the evicted tenants. “You will see the shells of the cottages to-morrow,” he said, “and you will judge for yourself what they were worth.” But the sympathy excited by the illustrations of the cruel conflagration and the heartrending descriptions of the reporters, resulted in a very handsome subscription for the benefit of the tenants of Glenbehy. General Sir William Butler, whose name came so prominently before the public in connection with his failure to appear and give evidence in a recent cause célèbre, and whose brother is a Resident Magistrate in Kerry, was one of the subscribers. The fund thus raised has been since administered by two trustees, Father Quilter, P.P., and Mr. Shee, a son of our brisk little landlady here, who maintain out of it very comfortably the evicted tenants. Not long ago a man in Tralee tried to bribe the agent into having him evicted, that he might make a claim on this fund! At Killorglin the Post-Office Savings Bank deposits, which stood at £282, 15s. 9d. in 1880, rose in 1887 to £1299, 2s. 6d. James Griffin, despite, or because, of the two evictions through which he has passed, is very well off. He owns a very good horse and cart, and seven or eight head of cattle. His arrears now amount to about £240, and on being urged yesterday to make a proposition which might avoid an eviction, he gravely offered to pay £8 of the current half-year’s rent in cash, and the remaining £5 in June, the landlord taking on himself all the costs and giving him a clean receipt! This liberal proposition was declined. The zeal of her son in behalf of the evicted tenants does not seem to affect the amiable anxiety of our trim and energetic hostess to make things agreeable here to the minions of the alien despotism. The officers both of the police and of the military appear to be on the best of terms with the whole household, and everything is going as merrily as marriage bells on this eve of an eviction.