eKtab
EN ع
The Testimony of the Rocks
or, Geology in Its Bearings on the Two Theologies, Natural and Revealed
Read free sample

The Testimony of the Rocks or, Geology in Its Bearings on the Two Theologies, Natural and Revealed

by Miller Hugh

Page 1

TESTIMONY OF THE ROCKS;

OR,

GEOLOGY IN ITS BEARINGS

ON THE

TWO THEOLOGIES, NATURAL AND REVEALED.

BY
HUGH MILLER,

AUTHOR OF "THE OLD RED SANDSTONE," "FOOTPRINTS OF THE
CREATOR," ETC., ETC.

WITH

MEMORIALS OF THE DEATH AND CHARACTER OF THE AUTHOR.


"Thou shalt be in league with the stones of the field."—Job.


 

 

BOSTON:
GOULD AND LINCOLN,
59 WASHINGTON STREET.
NEW YORK: SHELDON, BLAKEMAN & CO.
CINCINNATI: GEORGE S. BLANCHARD.
1857.


Entered according to Act of Congress, in the year 1857, by
GOULD AND LINCOLN,
In the Clerk's Office of the District Court of the District of Massachusetts.






Electro-Stereotyped
BY GEO. J. STILES,
23 Congress St., Boston.


TO

JAMES MILLER, ESQ., F.R.S.E.

PROFESSOR OF SURGERY IN THE UNIVERSITY OF EDINBURGH.

My Dear Sir,

This volume is chiefly taken up in answering, to the best of its author's knowledge and ability, the various questions which the old theology of Scotland has been asking for the last few years of the newest of the sciences. Will you pardon me the liberty I take in dedicating it to you? In compliance with the peculiar demand of the time, that what a man knows of science or of art he should freely communicate to his neighbors, we took the field nearly together as popular lecturers, and have at least so far resembled each other in our measure of success, that the same class of censors have been severe upon both. For while you have been condemned as a physiologist for asserting that the human framework, when fairly wrought during the week, is greatly the better for the rest of the Sabbath, I have been described by the same pen as one of the wretched class of persons who teach that geology, rightly understood, does not conflict with revelation. Besides, I owe it to your kindness that, when set aside by the indisposition which renders it doubtful whether I shall ever again address a popular audience, you enabled me creditably to fulfil one of my engagements by reading for me in public two of the following discourses, and by doing them an amount of justice on that occasion which could never have been done them by their author. Further, your kind attentions and advice during the crisis of my illness were certainly every way suited to remind me of those so gratefully acknowledged by the wit of the last century, when he bethought him of

"kind Arbuthnot's aid,
Who knew his art, but not his trade."

And so, though the old style of dedication has been long out of fashion, I avail myself of the opportunity it affords me of expressing my entire concurrence in your physiological views, my heartfelt gratitude for your good services and friendship, and my sincere respect for the disinterested part you have taken in the important work of elevating and informing your humbler countryfolk,—while at the same time maintaining professionally, with Simpson and with Goodsir, the reputation of that school of anatomy and medicine for which the Scottish capital has been long so famous.

I am,

My Dear Sir,

With sincere respect and regard,

Yours affectionately,

HUGH MILLER.


TO THE READER.

Of the twelve following Lectures, four (the First, Second, Fifth, and Sixth) were delivered before the members of the Edinburgh Philosophical Institution (1852 and 1855). One (the Third) was read at Exeter Hall before the Young Men's Christian Association (1854), and the substance of two of the others (the Eleventh and Twelfth) at Glasgow, before the Geological Section of the British Association (1855). Of the five others,—written mainly to complete and impart a character of unity to the volume of which they form a part,—only three (the Fourth, Seventh, and Eighth) were addressed viva voce to popular audiences. The Third Lecture was published both in this country and America, and translated into some of the Continental languages. The rest now appear in print for the first time. Though their writer has had certainly no reason to complain of the measure of favor with which the read or spoken ones have been received, they are perhaps all better adapted for perusal in the closet than for delivery in the public hall or lecture-room; while the two concluding Lectures are mayhap suited to interest only geologists who, having already acquainted themselves with the generally ascertained facts of their science, are curious to cultivate a further knowledge with such new facts as in the course of discovery are from time to time added to the common fund. In such of the following Lectures as deal with but the established geologic phenomena, and owe whatever little merit they may possess to the inferences drawn from these, or on the conclusions based upon them, most of the figured illustrations, though not all, will be recognized as familiar: in the two concluding Lectures, on the contrary, they will be found to be almost entirely new. They are contributions, representative of the patient gleanings of years, to the geologic records of Scotland; and exhibit, in a more or less perfect state, no inconsiderable portion of all the forms yet detected in the rocks of her earlier Palæozoic and Secondary floras.

It will be seen that I adopt, in my Third and Fourth Lectures, that scheme of reconciliation between the Geologic and Mosaic Records which accepts the six days of creation as vastly extended periods; and I have been reminded by a somewhat captious critic that I once held a very different view, and twitted with what he terms inconsistency. I certainly did once believe with Chalmers and with Buckland that the six days were simply natural days of twenty-four hours each,—that they had compressed the entire work of the existing creation,—and that the latest of the geologic ages was separated by a great chaotic gap from our own. My labors at the time as a practical geologist had been very much restricted to the Palæozoic and Secondary rocks, more especially to the Old Red and Carboniferous Systems of the one division, and the Oolitic System of the other; and the long extinct organisms which I found in them certainly did not conflict with the view of Chalmers. All I found necessary at the time to the work of reconciliation was some scheme that would permit me to assign to the earth a high antiquity, and to regard it as the scene of many succeeding creations. During the last nine years, however, I have spent a few weeks every autumn in exploring the later formations, and acquainting myself with their peculiar organisms. I have traced them upwards from the raised beaches and old coast lines of the human period, to the brick clays, Clyde beds, and drift and boulder deposits of the Pleistocene era, and again from these, with the help of museums and collections, up through the mammaliferous crag of England, to its Red and its Coral crags. And the conclusion at which I have been compelled to arrive is, that for many long ages ere man was ushered into being, not a few of his humbler contemporaries of the fields and woods enjoyed life in their present haunts, and that for thousands of years anterior to even their appearance, many of the existing molluscs lived in our seas. That day during which the present creation came into being, and in which God, when he had made "the beast of

Page 2
the earth after his kind, and the cattle after their kind," at length terminated the work by moulding a creature in his own image, to whom he gave dominion over them all, was not a brief period of a few hours' duration, but extended over mayhap millenniums of centuries. No blank chaotic gap of death and darkness separated the creation to which man belongs from that of the old extinct elephant, hippopotamus, and hyæna; for familiar animals such as the red deer, the roe, the fox, the wild cat, and the badger, lived throughout the period which connected their times with our own; and so I have been compelled to hold, that the days of creation were not natural, but prophetic days, and stretched far back into the bygone eternity. After in some degree committing myself to the other side, I have yielded to evidence which I found it impossible to resist; and such in this matter has been my inconsistency,—an inconsistency of which the world has furnished examples in all the sciences, and will, I trust, in its onward progress, continue to furnish many more.

Edinburgh, December, 1856.


[The last proofs of this preface were despatched by the Author to his printer only the day before that melancholy termination of his life, the details of which will be found in the "Memorials" following.—Am. Publishers.]


CONTENTS.

Page Memorials of the Death and Character of Hugh Miller, 7 LECTURE FIRST. The Palæontological History of Plants, 33 LECTURE SECOND. The Palæontological History of Animals, 86 LECTURE THIRD. The Two Records, Mosaic and Geological, 141 LECTURE FOURTH. The Mosaic Vision of Creation, 179 LECTURE FIFTH. Geology in its Bearings on the Two Theologies. Part I. 211 LECTURE SIXTH. Geology in its Bearings on the Two Theologies. Part II. 237 LECTURE SEVENTH. The Noachian Deluge. Part I. 283 LECTURE EIGHTH. The Noachian Deluge. Part II. 320 LECTURE NINTH. The Discoverable and the Revealed, 362 LECTURE TENTH. The Geology of the Anti-Geologists, 392 LECTURE ELEVENTH. On the Less Known Fossil Floras of Scotland. Part I. 429 LECTURE TWELFTH. On the Less Known Fossil Floras of Scotland. Part II. 463

List of Illustrations

PAGE A Restoration of Sphenopteris affinis (Frontispiece) 1. The Genealogy of Plants, 40 2. Cyclopteris Hibernicus, 42 3. Conifer of the Lower Old Red Sandstone, 43 4. The Genealogy of Animals, 45 5. Oldhamia antiqua (oldest known Zoophyte), 48 6. Palæochorda minor,
Page 3
align="right">49 7. Lycopodium clavatum, 51 8. Equisetum fluviatile, 51 9. Osmunda regalis (Royal Fern), 52 10. Pinus sylvestris (Scotch Fir), 53 11. Calamite? of the Lower Old Red Sandstone, 55 12. Lycopodite? of the Lower Old Red Sandstone, 55 13. Fern? of the Lower Old Red Sandstone, 56 14–19. Ferns of the Coal Measures, 58 20. Altingia excelsa (Norfolk Island Pine), 59 21. East Indian Fern (Asophila perrotetiana), 60 22. Section of Stem, of Tree-Fern (Cyathea), 60 23–25. Lepidodendron Sternbergii, 62 26. Calamites Mougeotii, 63 27. Sphenophyllum dentatum, 63 28. Sigillaria reniformis, 64 29. Sigillaria reniformis (nat. size), 65 30. Sigillaria pachyderma, 66 31. Stigmaria ficoides, 67 32. Favularia tessellata, 68 33. Lepidodendron obovatum, 68 34. Cycas revoluta, 69 35. Zamia pungens, 69 36. Zamia Feneonis, 69 37. Mantellia nidiformis, 70 38. Equisetum columnare, 71 39. Carpolithes conica, 72 40. Carpolithes Bucklandii, 72 41. Acer trilobatum, 73 42. Ulmus Bronnii (leaf of a tree allied to the Elm), 74 43. Palmacites Lamanonis (a Palm of the Miocene of Aix), 75 44. Cyclophthalmus Bucklandii (a
Page 4
Fossil Scorpion of the Coal Measures of Bohemia), 81 45. Fossil Dragon-Fly, 83 46. Cyathaxonia Dalmani, 88 47. Glyptocrinus decadactylus, 88 48. Calymene Blumenbachii, 89 49. Orthisina Verneuili, 89 50. Lituites cornu-arietis, 89 51. Lingula Lowisii, 89 52. Fort Jackson Shark (Cestracion Philippi), 91 53. The Genealogy of Fishes, 93 54. Amblypterus macropterus (a Ganoid of the Carboniferous System), 94 55. Lebias cephalotes (Cycloids of Aix), 94 56. Platax altissimus (a Ctenoid of Monte Bolca), 95 57. Pterichthys oblongus, 98 58. Pleuracanthus lævissimus, 100 59. Carcharias productus (Cutting Tooth), 101 60. Placodus gigas (Crushing Teeth), 101 61. Vespertilio Parisiensis (a Bat of the Eocene), 106 62. Ichthyosaurus communis, 106 63. Plesiosaurus dolichodeirus, 108 64. Pterodactylus crassirostris, 108 65. Chelonia Benstedi, 109 66. Palæophis Toliapicus (Ophidian of the Eocene), 110 67. Bird-tracks of the Connecticut, 113 68. Fossil Footprint, 114 69. Thylacotherium Prevosti, 117 70. Anoplotherium commune, 120 71. Animals of the Paris Basin, 121 72. Dinotherium giganteum, 122 73. Elephas primigenius (Great British Elephant), 127 74. Trogontherium Cuvieri (Gigantic Beaver), 128
Page 5
href="@public@vhost@g@gutenberg@html@files@28248@[email protected]#Fig_75" class="pginternal" tag="{http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml}a">75. Ursus spelæus (Cave Bear), 128 76. Hyæena Spelæa (Cave Hyæna), 129 77. Asaphus caudatus, 134 78. Orthoceras laterale, 134 79. Spirigerina reticularis, 134 80. Ammonites margaritatus, 134 81. Ammonites bisulcatus, 134 82. Belemnitella mucronata, 134 83. Belemnites sulcatus, 134 84. Murex alveolatus, 135 85. Astarte Omalli, 135 86. Balanus crassus, 136 87. Astarte arctica, 152 88. Tellina proxima, 152 89. Norwegian Spruce (Abies excelsa), 153 90. Lepidodendron Sternbergii, 164 91. Calamites cannæformis, 165 92. Megatherium Cuvieri, 167 93. Skull of Dinotherium giganteum 168 94. Ammonites Humphriesianus, 242 95. Encrinites moniliformis, 243 96. Cupressocrinus crassius, 243 97. Pentacrinus fasciculosus, 245 98. Chamfered and Imbricated Scales, 246 99. Scale of Holoptychius giganteus, 247 100. Section of Scale of Holoptychius, 248 101. Sigillaria Grœseri, 255 102–104. Whorled Shells of the Old Red Sandstone, 256 105. Murchisonia bigranulosa, 258 106. Conularia ornata, 258 107. Calico pattern (Manchester), 259
Page 6
class="pginternal" tag="{http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml}a">108. Smithia Pengellyi, 259 109. Apamæean Medal, 298 110. Old Mexican Picture, 299 111. Megaceros Hibernicus (Irish Elk), 331 112. Mylodon robustus, 346 113. Glyptodon clavipes, 346 114. The Geography of Cosmas, 376 115. The Heavens and Earth of Cosmas, 377 116. Nummulites lævigata (Pharaoh's Beans), 421 117. Silurian Organism, Graptolite, etc., 431 118. Fucoid, 433 119. Fucoids, 434 120. Plant resembling Lycopodium clavatum, 437 121. Parka decipiens, 449 122. Fossil Fern (probably), 450 123. Unnamed Fossil Plant, 450 124. Cyclopterus Hibernicus, 458 125. New and peculiar Fern from Airdrie coal field, 464 126. Stigmaria, 465 127. The same, magnified, 465 128. Stigmaria, 466 129. Sphenopteris bifida, 470 130. Conifers? 475 131. Conifer Twigs, 476 132. Unnamed Fossil Plant, 478 133. Zamia, 479 134. Zamia, 480 135. Zamia of the Lias, 481 136. Zamia of the Oolite, 481 137. Zamia resembling Z. lanceolata, 482 138. Fossil Cone, 483 139. Fossil Cone, 484
Page 7
140. Helmsdale Fossil Plants, 485 141. Fossil Ferns in Helmsdale Deposits, 486 142. Unnamed Fossil Plant, 488 143. Pecopteris obtusifolia, 489 144. Apparent Fern (new), 490 145. Pachypteris, 490 146. Phlebopteris, 491 147. Unnamed Fossil Plant, 492 148. Pentagon, illustrative of Fern allies, 493 149. Imbricated Stem, 494 150. Fossil Plant (Helmsdale), 495 151. Dicotyledonous Leaf of the Oolite, 496 152. Fern, 497

MEMORIALS

OF

HUGH MILLER.


Unknown he came. He went a Mystery—
A mighty vessel foundered in the calm,
Her freight half-given to the world. To die
He longed, nor feared to meet the great "I AM."
Fret not. God's mystery is solved to him.
He quarried Truth all rough-hewn from the earth,
And chiselled it into a perfect gem—
A rounded Absolute. Twain at a birth—
Science with a celestial halo crowned,
And Heavenly Truth—God's Works by His Word illumed—
These twain he viewed in holiest concord bound.
Reason outsoared itself. His mind consumed
By its volcanic fire, and frantic driven,
He dreamed himself in hell and woke in heaven.

Edinburgh, December, 1856.


MEMORIALS

OF THE

DEATH AND CHARACTER OF HUGH MILLER,

WITH AN

ACCOUNT OF HIS FUNERAL OBSEQUIES.

Near the end of last autumn the American publishers of Hugh Miller's works received from him, through his Edinburgh publishers, the offer of a new work from his pen. The offer was accepted and a contract was at once closed. Soon the advance sheets began to come; and as successive portions were received and perused, it became more and more evident that the work was destined not only to extend his fame, but to establish for him new and special claims to the admiration and gratitude of mankind. In the midst of these anticipations, and ere more than half the sheets had been received, the publishers and the public here were startled by the news that Mr. Miller had come to a violent death. The paragraph conveying the intelligence was such as to leave the mind in a state of painful suspense. But the next steamer from Europe brought full details of the lamentable event. It appeared that in a momentary fit of mental aberration he had died by his own hand, on the night of December 23d, 1856. The cause was over much brain-work. He had been long and incessantly engaged in preparing the present work for the press, when, just as he had given the last touches to the eloquent, the immortal record, reason abandoned her throne, and in the brief interregnum, that great light of science was quenched forever.

The event caused universal lamentation throughout the British Isles. It was treated as a public calamity. The British press, from the London Times to the remotest provincial newspaper, gave expression to the general sorrow in strains of unwonted eloquence; and in so doing recounted his great services to the cause of science, and paid homage to his genius.

Some of the articles which the event thus called forth have seemed to the American publishers worthy of preservation, from the authentic facts which they embody, the judgments which they express, and the literary excellence by which they are marked. They have therefore determined to print them in connection with this work as permanent Memorials of its distinguished and lamented author.

The first piece appeared in the Edinburgh Witness of December 27th, 1856,—the paper of which Mr. Miller had been the editor from its establishment in 1840. It presents an authentic account of the circumstances attending his death, and is understood to be from the pen of the Rev. William Hanna, L.L.D., the son-in-law and biographer of Dr. Chalmers, and sometime editor of the North British Review.